We're here to serve you

Home

Auto

Commercial Auto

Business

Life

Recreational Vehicle

Welcome to Butler Insurance Agency

YOUR INSURANCE IS SERVED.

Butler’s Insurance Agency offers customized Home, Auto, Boat, Condo, Renters, RV, Motorcycle, Life, and Umbrella insurance policies from numerous insurance brands including Appalachian Underwriters, Bankers, Bristol West, Foremost, Hagerty, Hippo, Johnson and Johnson, Nationwide, Progressive, Safeco, SageSure and many more. Residents in and around Columbia now can experience a better way to buy insurance for their homes, vehicles, and much more as veteran Insurance Agency Owner, Tasha Butler, is located at 1617 Broad River Road in Columbia (in the Boozer Shopping Center). Hours of operation are Monday through Friday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. (EST) and Saturday/Sunday by appointment.

Instant Insurance Quote

In a hurry? Get a quote on your insurance policy instantly.

Get Started!
Get an instant quote today!

We Are
Here For
You

Get Started With a Quote

Featured Carriers

Allstate Logo
Appalachian Underwriters Logo
Bankers Logo
Bristol West Logo
Encompass Logo
Foremost Logo
Hagerty Logo
Hartford Logo
Hippo Logo
Johnson and Johnson Logo
Nationwide Logo
Progressive Logo
Safeco Logo
Sagesure Logo

Where do I begin? Walking into this insurance office made my day to say the least! I was greeted by the most professional yet down to earth staff ever. Mrs. Butler helped me choose the insurance policy that fit my...

-Kim Dibble

I highly recommend anyone to switch over or get a free quote. I was introduced to Butler’s Insurance few years ago. I always receive excellent customer service, staff members are friendly, professional, fast responses. Thank you again for everything you...

-Audrey Paschoal

Very professional and intentional team. Tasha Butler went above and beyond to ensure our needs were accurately met. Her service exceeds expectations. Highly recommended!

-Tammie Anderson

Mrs. Butler is kind and knowledgeable. She is a great person to work with. She always has the best interest of the client.

-Shelley James (ShelleyLJ)

Great Service ! Save me money!

-Tommy C.

Thank you so much for helping me get a better quote for my car insurance. Again I appreciate your great customer service and patience. May God continue to bless you and your businesses!!! — feeling relieved.

-Lynette A,

Butler insurance is a great company. Tasha Butler is very professional and will help you get the best quote on any type of insurance you’re looking for! Very customer friendly and I can assure that you won’t be disappointed

-Ashley W.

View More

What Clients Say

Our Latest Articles

September 18, 2025

Understanding the Different Types of Business Insurance

Running a business sometimes requires juggling day-to-day operations and unexpected financial challenges. Business insurance addresses common risks, and can be […]

July 27, 2025

Understanding Liability Coverage in Your Home Insurance Policy

Liability coverage is one of the most essential parts of your homeowners insurance policy, but it’s often overlooked until something […]

May 29, 2025

How Surety Bonds Can Help You Win More Contracts

In the competitive world of business, securing contracts can be crucial for growth and sustainability. Carrying surety bonds can significantly […]